Call us 24/7 for a Free Consultation

520-882-8823

Blog

How to choose a good criminal defense lawyer?

Request Free Consultation

Se habla español

By Josh Hamilton on

Criminal defense lawyer shaking hands with his client

Being charged with a crime is a scary and stressful experience. Luckily, with a good lawyer, you can manage the stress. A good criminal defense lawyer can make a big difference in the outcome of your case. But with so many lawyers out there, how do you find the right one? This guide will help you choose the right criminal defense lawyer.

Learn how to choose a criminal defense lawyer wisely to protect your rights. Get expert advice and find the best criminal defense attorney for your case at the Law Office of Hernandez | Hamilton | Lamoureux.

Why Hire A Criminal Defense Lawyer

The legal system is complicated, and criminal charges can have serious consequences for your freedom, reputation, and future. Here’s why you need a criminal defense attorney:

  • Understanding the Charges: Legal terms can be confusing. A lawyer explains the charges you face, potential penalties, and your rights.
  • Building a Strong Defense: They analyze evidence, identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and develop a solid defense strategy.
  • Protecting Your Rights: Lawyers ensure law enforcement follows proper procedures and protects you from saying anything that could harm your criminal case.
  • Negotiating Options: They can negotiate plea bargains to potentially reduce charges or sentences.
  • Courtroom Experience: A lawyer confidently represents you in court, ensuring a fair trial. 

Overall, a criminal lawyer is your advocate who’ll make certain you go through the legal system effectively and have the best chance of a positive outcome.

Handcuffs with gavel on a table

Choosing A Criminal Defense Lawyer

When facing criminal charges, selecting the right defense attorney is integral. According to a study by the American Bar Association, a competent defense attorney can significantly impact case outcomes, emphasizing the importance of this decision. When choosing the right lawyer: 

  1. Evaluate the experience and expertise of the criminal defense lawyer

When choosing a good criminal defense attorney, it’s vital to consider their experience and expertise in handling cases similar to yours. Look for a lawyer with a proven criminal law track record and a deep understanding of the legal nuances involved in your specific type of case.You can find this information by researching online profiles. Many lawyers have websites that showcase their experience and areas of practice. Look for testimonials from past clients facing similar charges. Legal directories and bar association websites can also be helpful resources. Don’t hesitate to ask the lawyer directly about their experience with cases like yours during your consultation.This evaluation is important because a lawyer’s experience and expertise directly impact their ability to build a strong defense, handle legal complexities, and ultimately secure the best possible outcome for your case.

  1. Assess the success rate and track record of a criminal defense lawyer

In the legal field, a lawyer’s “success rate” can be tricky. Wins and losses aren’t always clear-cut. Dismissed charges, reduced sentences, and successful plea bargains all contribute to a positive track record.So, how do you assess this?  Review the lawyer’s website and ask directly about their experience with cases similar to yours. What were the typical outcomes? Did they achieve dismissals, acquittals, or favorable plea bargains?Keep in mind that lawyers can’t guarantee results, and every case is unique.  However, their experience with similar cases offers valuable insight into their approach and past successes. This can help you gauge their effectiveness in navigating your specific situation

.
  1. Consider specialization and knowledge in specific areas of criminal law

Criminal law covers a vast landscape, from traffic violations to complex white-collar crimes.  Just like in medicine, lawyers often develop expertise in specific areas. The following are common specializations.

  • Violent Crimes: Murder, assault, domestic violence. These cases require lawyers skilled in complex investigations and trial strategies.
  • Property Crimes: Theft, robbery, burglary –  these lawyers understand property law and know how to fight for reduced charges.
  • DUI/DWI: Driving under the influence requires expertise in traffic law and breathalyzer tests to build a strong defense.
  • White-Collar Crimes: Embezzlement, fraud, money laundering. These complex financial crimes require lawyers familiar with complex financial regulations.
  • Drug Crimes: These cases benefit from lawyers who understand drug sentencing laws and potential alternative programs.

A lawyer who focuses on a specific area of criminal law has in-depth knowledge of the relevant laws, procedures, and potential defenses. They’ve likely handled cases similar to yours before, giving them a strategic advantage in building a strong defense on your behalf. Their specialized knowledge ensures they leverage the latest legal developments and strategies to fight in your unique case.

  1. Explore the availability and accessibility of a criminal defense lawyer

A lawyer’s brilliance is not the only relevant factor. You need someone readily available to address your concerns and guide you through the legal maze. Don’t be surprised if some lawyers seem perpetually booked.  Criminal defense attorneys often juggle multiple cases, court appearances, and other pressing matters.So, how do you separate genuine busyness from empty promises? Here are some red flags:

  • Long response times: Emails and calls go unanswered for days.
  • Vague scheduling: They offer “flexible” appointments with no concrete availability.
  • Constant hand-offs: You’re shuffled between paralegals or associates, rarely connecting with the actual lawyer.

Look for a lawyer who prioritizes communication. During consultations, gauge their responsiveness. Do they answer your questions directly?  Do they outline a communication plan to keep you informed? A lawyer who values accessibility demonstrates their commitment to your case and your peace of mind.

  1. Understand the fee structure and cost implications

Different types of fee structures are commonly offered by criminal defense lawyers. These may include hourly rates, where you pay for the lawyer’s time spent on your case, flat fees, which cover all legal services for a specific phase or entirety of the case, or contingency fees, where the lawyer’s fee is contingent upon winning the case.To ensure you’re not being overcharged, compare fee structures among different lawyers and inquire about typical costs associated with cases similar to yours. Request a written fee agreement that outlines all costs and expenses upfront, including any additional fees or expenses that may arise throughout the legal process.Other considerations include the availability of payment plans or financing options, potential factors that may affect the overall cost of representation, such as the complexity of the case or length of the trial, and any potential fee disputes or conflicts of interest. Remember, the cheapest option isn’t always the best. 

  1. Assess the communication style and rapport with a criminal defense lawyer

A criminal defense lawyer is your partner in a stressful situation. Clear communication is crucial. You need someone who explains complex legal concepts in understandable terms and keeps you informed throughout the process. Here’s what to look for:

Active Listener

Does the lawyer pay close attention to your concerns and ask clarifying questions? A lawyer who actively listens demonstrates their commitment to understanding your unique situation.

Transparent Communication

Does the lawyer explain the legal process clearly, outlining the potential risks and benefits of different options? You deserve a lawyer who avoids legalese and ensures you’re part of the decision-making process.

Comfort and Confidence

During consultations, do you feel comfortable talking openly and honestly with the lawyer? Trust your gut. A strong lawyer-client relationship is built on mutual respect and confidence.Also, beyond clear communication, a good lawyer builds rapport. You’ll be sharing confidential details and relying on their guidance. If you don’t feel a connection during consultations, keep searching. 

  1. Seek references and testimonials from past clients

Don’t just take a lawyer’s word for it. Ask for references from past clients who faced similar charges. Online reviews can also offer valuable insights. Positive testimonials from satisfied clients serve as a strong endorsement of the lawyer’s effectiveness and communication style. Look for reviews that mention responsiveness, clear explanations, and positive outcomes.

Understanding The Role Of Confidentiality And Trust

Being accused of a crime can be isolating. A strong defense relies on a lawyer you can completely trust. In criminal law, this trust is built on a foundation of confidentiality. This means anything you tell your lawyer stays confidential, like a secret between you two. The law (attorney-client privilege) protects these communications, ensuring your honesty is safeguarded. 

Why is this so important? 

Complete honesty allows your lawyer to see the whole picture. With all the details, even the uncomfortable ones, they can craft the most effective defense possible. Like a puzzle, the more pieces you have, the clearer the picture. 

Confidentiality allows your lawyer to gather all the pieces, identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and explore every possible defense option. Without this trust and open communication, your defense may be hindered, potentially jeopardizing your future.

Consult with a Trusted Criminal Defense Lawyer

Are you looking for the right Criminal Defense Attorney? The Law Office of Hernandez | Hamilton | Lamoureux stands by your side. Our experienced attorneys have a deep understanding of the criminal justice system, providing the best possible defense for every client. We offer a variety of services, from legal advice to courtroom representation, all while safeguarding your rights and fighting for a favorable outcome in your case. Call us today for a free consultation about your case.

Back to Blog
520-882-8823

Request a Consultation Today

Request a Consultation

Client Testimonials

Clay Hernandez and Josh Hamilton are some of the most competent Lawyers I have ever had the pleasure of working with. They are dedicated, hard working and honest! They are some of the top Lawyers in the legal community and you couldn't have a better legal team on your side!

Lacee

To say that Josh Hamilton saved my life would be an understatement. Facing an incredibly ugly situation, I shopped around for an attorney for a while until I came across Mr. Hamilton. From day one I knew I had found the representation I needed. Josh fought tooth and nail for me and got me the best outcome, considering the dire straits I was in. His staff is incredibly helpful and friendly and Josh's ability and knowledge of the law is second to none. I could not see myself facing a hell like this again with anyone else at my side. A simple "thank you" will never be enough for all that Josh and the staff of Hernandez and Hamilton did for me.

Ox Inator

If you need a criminal defense lawyer then Josh Hamilton is definitely your guy!! Not only is he beyond brilliant.. and amazing at what he does! But he is a very caring and compassionate person. I highly recommend him!! He worked very hard on my case and got it dropped!!

Racquel Vera

The absolute 100% best. I cannot stress how much I appreciate and how grateful i am for Josh and Carol. They took up my brothers case in 2018 and never left him since. Their work is excellent and speaks volume. The complexity of the case will have anybody fearful and doubtful but not them. Right from the start they maintained a positive vibe and their professionalism is exceptional. I am so happy i found them back when me and my sister in law were googling appellate lawyers. If i could hug them now i would. My brother was released two days ago and even though the case is not done i am pretty sure the end results will be a good one. God appointed the right lawyers and they are not in it for the money they truly are genuine in fighting for victory and they know what happened to my brothers were not right and they fought tooth and nail and for that i just want to say thank you from the bottom of my heart. Grateful forever and ever!

King Black

I had a potential federal case come before me in my work environment. I called and they were so willing to work with me on getting into an in person consultation even though I was 2 hours away. We spoke on the phone, and then had a meeting I specifically spoke with Clay. He was knowledgeable and had a defense prepared before I even left the consultation. With everything still being in process, all I can tell you, based on my experience with him, he will fight until the end and he won't give up!

Cynthia Bass

Hernandez & Hamilton are top-notch attorneys. In hindsight I would NOT have considered hiring any other attorney to take care of my legal matters. Hernandez even traveled out of state to represent me over 2000 miles away, in Ohio, IN THE WINTER. :) Thank you for all you have done for me and my family!!!

Kari Turner

The best thing about this law office is their dedication. Josh never stopped working for us, never stopped believing that there would be a great outcome and even when it looked like all hope was lost, he kept working until we got the outcome we were looking for. I would recommend this office to anyone looking for an attorney. If they believe they can help, they will!!

Sarah Tecco

I contacted Mr. Hamilton regarding a case involving my brother. From the moment we spoke on the phone, he made feel like we were in the right hands. We discussed the case, went over the pro´s and con´s reaching a desicion to move fwd with the case. Mr. Hamilton is extremely well prepared and very knowledgagle. My brother got a very long punishment that was not justified and because of his commitment to the case and his great team effort, they got my brother a reduced sentence to time served. Now, thanks to Mr. Hamilton and his team, my brother is able to reunite with his three kids and his brothers. We are for ever thankful for your hard work and commitment. Thank you for believing in whats right! Blessings from our entire family.

Eghector

Josh Hamilton is top-notch: knowledgeable, accessible, hard-working and honest. No better lawyer in town.

Jeff Welter

I highly recommend Josh Hamilton to resolve your legal issues.The staff at Hernandez and Hamilton were very professional and friendly.Thank you Josh,Julie, Roni, and Olivia for everything that you all did for us. Have a wonderful holiday season and a prosperous new year..

Gillbert Encinas

I have owned a private investigation company in Arizona for a quarter century and worked with both of these lawyers for many years. These attorneys are honest, extremely competent, and truly care about their clients. Both are exceptional advocates.

Randy Downer

Josh is one of the best lawyers out there. He has helped me in multiple situations and has gotten me off every time. He’s professional about everything and I highly recommend him.

Timothy Marshall

I needed the best attorney in town and Josh did not let me down. If you want an aggressive pro-active team representing you, this is the outfit to go with. Best in class.

Organic BTI

I hired Hernandez & Hamilton to take care of a friend who had a bit of a tough situation. They took care of him easily and kept the cops honest. Very happy.

Danton Foster

Best lawyer in town. Josh and everyone else working with him at his law office go beyond to help you every step of the way. I would highly recommend for your criminal defense attorney.

Martin Lopez

Fantastic work by Josh and his team, they are very professional. Thank you for your help in our case. You and your team managed to get my brother released on the spot and cleared of all charges.

Eftimi Etzoglou

If you want the best of the best? Look no further because Clay and Josh are definitely it. HANDS DOWN.

Amanda Wade-Mcmickle

I can't thank Josh Hamilton enough and his team for what they did for our family to give us peace knowing that we got the best law firm the best lawyer and the out come was amazing thank you for all your knowledge your hard work your dedication once again thank you Josh and your team.

Alley Prudhomme

Excellent firm with outstanding attorneys and staff. They work extremely hard and get amazing results for their clients.

Adam dippel

This legal team is at the top of their game when it comes to representation and dedication. Truly a 5 Star law firm from beginning to end.

Mary Domoto-Hill

Mr. Hamilton is an absolute beast and he handled my problem like a Sunday drive. Absolutely the best attorney anywhere.period. thank you again Mr. Hamilton. Five stars across the board.

James Stewart