By Josh Hamilton on
Domestic violence laws are designed to protect individuals from abuse within intimate or familial relationships, encompassing a range of behaviors such as physical assault, emotional abuse, and stalking. However, there are instances where an accused individual may have acted in self-defense to protect themselves from imminent harm. Self-defense claims in domestic violence cases assert that the accused’s actions were a necessary response to an immediate threat posed by the alleged victim.
In Arizona, self-defense is a legally recognized justification that can be used to counter domestic violence charges. According to Arizona Revised Statutes § 13-404, a person is justified in using physical force against another when they reasonably believe it is necessary to protect themselves from imminent unlawful physical force.
Role of Hernandez Hamilton Loamoureux PC in Defending Such Cases
The Law Office of Hernandez Hamilton Loamoureux PC, located in Arizona, specializes in criminal defense, with a strong focus on domestic violence cases. Our experienced attorneys are adept at navigating the complexities of self-defense claims and provide robust legal representation for individuals accused of domestic violence. We can successfully claim self-defense by meticulously evaluating the circumstances surrounding each case, gathering crucial evidence, and presenting compelling arguments in court. Our firm strives to ensure that clients’ rights are protected and that justice is served.
If you are facing allegations of domestic violence or seeking to assert a self-defense claim after physical harm, Hernandez Hamilton Loamoureux PC offers the expertise and dedication needed to achieve a fair and favorable outcome. Contact us today to speak with a domestic violence attorney.
Legal Definitions and Different Types of Domestic Violence in Arizona
Legal Definitions
In Arizona, domestic violence is defined under Arizona Revised Statutes § 13-3601. Domestic violence encompasses a wide range of criminal acts committed by one family or household member against another. The statute outlines various relationships that qualify under domestic violence, including:
- Spouses or former spouses
- Individuals who cohabit or have cohabited
- Individuals who have a child in common
- Blood relatives or relatives by marriage
- Individuals currently or previously in a romantic or sexual relationship
The law aims to protect victims by categorizing specific acts as domestic violence when committed within these relationships.
Different Types of Domestic Violence
Domestic violence can manifest in several forms, each with unique characteristics and legal implications. Here are the common types recognized in Arizona:
Physical Abuse
Definition: The intentional use of physical force to cause harm
Examples: Hitting, slapping, punching, shoving, strangling, or using a weapon against the victim in any way that causes bodily harm
Emotional Abuse
Definition: Behaviors that undermine an individual’s self-worth or emotional well-being
Examples: Insults, humiliation, constant criticism, manipulation, and threats
Sexual Abuse
Definition: Any non-consensual sexual act or behavior
Examples: Rape, sexual assault, forced sexual acts, and any form of sexual coercion
Economic Abuse
Definition: Controlling or manipulating an individual’s financial resources
Examples: Restricting access to money, forbidding employment, and controlling financial decisions
Psychological Abuse
Definition: Actions intended to instill fear, isolation, or intimidation
Examples: Threats of harm, destruction of property, and isolating the victim from friends and family
Stalking
Definition: Repeated and unwanted attention or harassment that causes fear
Examples: Following the victim, sending unwanted messages or gifts, and monitoring their activities
Cyberstalking
Definition: The use of electronic communication to harass or intimidate
Examples: Persistent unwanted emails, social media harassment, and online threats
Legal Protections and Consequences
Victims of domestic violence in Arizona can seek protection through legal measures such as Orders of Protection and Injunctions Against Harassment. These court-issued directives can prohibit the abuser from contacting or approaching the victim. They may include provisions for removing the abuser from a shared residence and granting temporary custody of children.
Perpetrators of domestic violence face serious legal consequences, including criminal charges that range from misdemeanors to felonies. Penalties can include imprisonment, fines, mandatory counseling, and restraining orders.
Understanding the legal definitions and various forms of domestic violence is crucial for both victims seeking protection and individuals facing accusations.
Scenarios Where Self-Defense is Applicable
Immediate Threat and Response
Self-defense is legally justified when an individual reasonably believes they are in imminent danger of harm and must act to protect themselves. In the context of domestic violence, this means that the accused must have faced an immediate threat of unlawful physical force.
Here are some scenarios where self-defense might be applicable:
Physical Assault: If an individual is being physically attacked by their partner — such as being hit, slapped, or strangled — they may use reasonable force to defend themselves and stop the assault. If you have defensive wounds and medical records to back up a claim that you responded in a way any reasonable person would against immediate danger, this helps your defense.
Imminent Harm Against Perceived Danger: If the accused perceives an imminent threat, such as their partner brandishing a weapon or making credible threats of imminent violence, they may act in self-defense to prevent bodily injury.
Proportional Use of Force
The force used in self-defense must be proportional to the threat faced. This means that the response should not exceed what is necessary to protect oneself from harm. Here are some examples:
Minimal Force: If an individual faces a minor threat, such as being pushed, they should respond with minimal force, such as going back to create distance.
Equal Force: If the threat involves a more significant level of violence, such as being punched or attacked with a weapon, the individual may use an equivalent level of force to defend themselves, such as striking back or using an object for protection.
Excessive Force: Using excessive force, such as responding to a slap with a potentially lethal action, may not be considered justified self-defense and could result in criminal charges.
Previous Threats or Abuse as Context
Previous threats or a history of abuse can provide important context for a self-defense claim. While the immediate situation is crucial, the past behavior of the alleged abuser can help establish why the accused reasonably believed they were in imminent danger. Consider these scenarios:
Pattern of Abuse: If an individual has a documented history of being physically, emotionally, or psychologically abused by their partner, this history can support their claim that they acted in self-defense. The past abuse helps demonstrate that the accused had a reasonable belief that the threat was real and imminent.
Escalating Threats: If the accused has been subjected to escalating threats of violence, even if those threats were not acted upon previously, this can provide context for why they felt the need to defend themselves in a particular situation. If friends or family members were present, witness statements will help back up your claim.
Understanding these scenarios is vital in proving a self-defense claim in domestic violence cases. The legal system recognizes that individuals have the right to protect themselves from harm, but the justification must be clearly established through evidence and the context of the threat faced.
Contact a Criminal Defense Attorney When Claiming Self Defense
Hernandez Hamilton Loamoureux PC offers expert legal assistance for individuals charged with domestic violence, including self-defense claims. We provide a free consultation to evaluate your case and understand your unique circumstances. Our experienced attorneys will meticulously build a robust defense strategy for your domestic violence situation, gathering evidence and leveraging our deep knowledge of Arizona domestic violence laws.
With a commitment to protecting your rights, we offer dedicated legal defense in court, advocating on your behalf to achieve the best possible outcome. Trust Hernandez Hamilton Loamoureux PC to guide you through this challenging time with professionalism and expertise.
Back to Blog